It should have been a five star. It is beautiful, but it has a couple injuries so four stars it gets. There is a dent in one of the metal insets in the stones, and looks like one stone has been broken and patched with a black material, tar ?, Not enough damage that I'd send it back. Also the box was in terrible condition, re used ?, it had been taped back together, looked as if it had been opened before, and had several holes in it. Maybe if shipped in new box it should be marked FRAGILE?