I bought the lodge small and the Amazon basics regular one and the Lodge regular one and a 2 pack of the quilted cast iron pan holders at the same time. Quick review- They all work well, they all are loose on the pans, They should not be left on the pans, but slipped on when deeded. The small lodge grip is too small for my 12"" pan but fine on smaller ones. I wish the quilted ones had a little more padding, but they are enough- even holding and caring the hot pans they stay cool enough.Results: My favorites in order- The quilted ones (easy to slip on and off and will work on any pan. The Amazon basics have little bumps that help the grip a little so it probably comes in ahead of the lodge, but for smaller pans the small lodge one is better.Hope this helps- I like all of these better than a regular hot pad.